405 McNeary Street, Prosperity, SC 29127 MLS #643895 Home Real Estate Newberry Prosperity 29127 405 McNeary Street Share Ask Realtor Saving Save Saved405 McNeary Street | #643895 For Sale - $445,000Prosperity, SC 29127 405 McNeary Street | #643895 For Sale - $445,000 Share Ask Realtor Saving Save Saved MLS ID: 643895 For Sale - $445,000 About this property Bedrooms 4 Baths 3 sq2 3860 Lot Size 0.7500 acres Year Built 1910 DOM 3AddressAddress:405 McNeary StreetCity: ProsperityZip Code: 29127County: NewberryState: SCFeatures and Amenities #masterdownLocation IslandCooling Central, Split System, Multiple Units, Heat Pump 1st LvlHeating Gas 1st Lvl, Gas 2nd LvlFoundation Crawl SpaceStories 4Water PublicKitchen Floors-Vinyl, Floors-Laminate, Backsplash-Other, Cabinets-Painted, Prep Sink, Counter Tops-QuartzAppliances Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Microwave Countertop, Tankless H20Master Bedroom Tub-Shower, Ceilings-High (over 9 Ft), Bath-Shared, Closet-PrivateDownstairs Ceiling FanInterior Features Attic Storage, Attic Pull-Down AccessFireplace Features Insert, Gas Log-NaturalOther Cable, Security Cameras, Antebellum, No Basement Show all features Description Step into a beautifully preserved piece of Prosperity history: the Dr. J.I. Bedenbaugh House, built between 1895 to 1910 and closely associated with one of the town's earliest physicians and a founder of the local Prosperity Drugstore. Set on just under an acre with only one neighboring property, this stately home provides exceptional privacy while maintaining just a short golf-cart ride from Main Street's shops, restaurants, and community life.A breathtaking stairwell provides a stunning backdrop for future family pictures and grand entrances. French doors off the dining room lead you into your own sunroom sanctuary which has doors that open onto a miraculous wrap-around porch- gracefully wrapping around the entire front of the home by more than 12 columns- perfect for morning coffee or evening gatherings. A newly installed heat-pump and central AC system with brand new ductwork keeps the home's climate comfortable year-round while preserving its historic character. Not to mention the value added with the new tankless hot water heater.Sun-soaked bay windows transforms and frames beautiful views that enhance the home's period charm and invites natural light into its elegant rooms. In the kitchen with towering ceilings, enjoy the new quartz countertops, multi-functional workstation sink, while testing your culinary skills on a new GE natural-gas slide-in 5-burner range with built-in air fryer, pizza oven, and convection functions. The residence preserves period character and craftsmanship while offering versatile spaces for contemporary living and entertaining. Mature landscaping creates peaceful outdoor getaways and plenty of area for gardens or pool. With easy downtown access and a pace that suits both weekend riders and daily commuters, this is a rare opportunity for a steward who values architectural heritage, privacy, and small-town convenience.Owner needs at least 1 hour notice before showing. Disclaimer: CMLS has not reviewed and, therefore, does not endorse vendors who may appear in listings.Schools 9-12 SPED 6-8 SPED PK-5 SPED Name Address Phone Type Grade Mid-Carolina High 377 Cy Schumpert Road 8033642134 Public 9-12 SPED Name Address Phone Type Grade Mid-Carolina Middle 6794 US Highway 76 8033643634 Public 6-8 SPED Name Address Phone Type Grade Prosperity-Rikard Elementary 381 South Wheeler Street 8033642321 Public PK-5 SPED All Neighborhoods in Prosperity ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ subdivision Active Listings Avg Days on Market Avg DoM Avg Price A ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ autumns cay , Prosperity 118$74,500 B bedford way , Prosperity 152$629,900 blacksgate east , Prosperity 253$507,400 breakwater at woodside shores , Prosperity 19261$176,346 E edgewater shores , Prosperity 273$632,500 G grant williams estates , Prosperity 2114$224,500 H harbor view estates , Prosperity 5111$696,460 holiday acres , Prosperity 168$675,000 L lake murray , Prosperity 20115$932,986 lands end at woodside shores , Prosperity 16236$221,297 M mariners pointe , Prosperity 160$879,000 N newberry shores , Prosperity 784$314,127 O osprey pointe , Prosperity 2258$924,950 other , Prosperity 1182$147,000 P paddlers cove at woodside shores , Prosperity 185$747,370 plantation pointe , Prosperity 1151$345,000 R rolling hills , Prosperity 1215$315,827 S shelter bay , Prosperity 248$349,950 stewart landing , Prosperity 27144$210,057 summer oaks , Prosperity 117$225,000 sweetwater , Prosperity 119$815,000 T the pointes of plantation pointe , Prosperity 3170$1,039,333 Mortgage Calculator Price: $ Down Payment: $ % Term(*in years): Interest Rate in %: % Interest Rate as of: Thu, Oct. 01, 2026 $445,000Home Price $445,000Monthly payment $445,000Amount Financed $445,000Annual cost of Loan Get Approved Map SEE THIS PROPERTY James Schiller Realtor, Brand Name Real Estate Email: [email protected] Live Chat: Reviews Your Email: Your Name: Phone: Subject: I WANT TO VIEW THIS PROPERTYI'D LIKE TO MAKE AN OFFERWHAT ARE THE FEES?ASK A QUESTION Message: Send Suggested Listings Previus Next ©2026 CTMLS, GGMLS, CCMLS & CMLS 803-405-0054The information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS boards of the SC Realtors. Listing Provided by Lane Properties 405 McNeary Street, Prosperity, SC, 29127 MLS: #643895 $445,000 Share Contact Realtor Saving Save Saved